A Story Of Airport To Nowhere: Is Navi Mumbai Airport Finally Ready To Take Off?

The story of Mumbai’s second airport

Mumbai, India’s commercial capital, contributes over 20% to Maharashtra’s GDP. An important city by many measures, it accounts for 16% of India’s total airport passenger flows, 28% of total air-cargo flows and 15% of total aircraft movements. The connectivity is critical given the confluence of service and trade oriented industries. Yet it is a city that is constrained on airport capacity and the second airport has been in the planning and execution stages since 2008. 12 years later, what is the status of the second airport?

The Navi-Mumbai airport, a complex project on all fronts

The airport project traces its roots back to 1997 when the central government constituted a committee to examine a site. The proposed site was Eastwards in an area called Navi-Mumbai and after an extensive feasibility study, the project received in-principle approval from the Union Cabinet in 2007. Approvals from the state government soon followed and by the end of 2010 most approvals were in place. Yet the largest hurdles were still to come. These included land acquisition, the diversion of a river which otherwise would flow right across the airport runways, and also relocation of high-voltage lines – to name a few. There was also the challenge of environmental clearances given that the site was in marsh land and close to mangroves. Given the overall sentiment, stakeholders were optimistic that they would be able to drive consensus and take the project forward. However, the challenges had just begun.

Socio-political realities almost ended the project, challenges are ongoing

The Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) gave its clearance for the Navi Mumbai airport project in 2008. Several objections were put up and the project awaited further clearances which only came in 2010. At which time new objections were put up.

The challenge was perhaps compounded given the complexity of the project. Given the nature of the land that included wetlands and mangroves in and around the airport site, even to get the land ready would include a host of measures. Starting froom flattening of a hill from 90 meters to 10 meters, land reclamation, diverting a river (the Ulwe river), widening the channel and making sure that the land does not settle upon construction (for which it needed to be raised by 3 – 5 meters). Much of this work has now been completed but each step posed new hurdles. Ironically, in a country that likes to debate all things, this engineering success was never celebrated.

Perhaps the greatest challenge that was faced was land acquisition – something common with most infrastructure projects. Mostly because of the social and political consequences and timelines. In an environment where there is always an election looming, the agendas simply done align. And a diverse political base translates to very different promises made too segments. Infrastructure projects often get caught up in narrative distortion where micro-narratives are built including how the project is detrimental for one or more citizen groups. In the case of Navi-Mumbai this was no different. Initially there were challenges on resettlement and quantum of payments. Then there were issues around livelihood and skill development. And then there was political posturing. As a result, several villages and inhabitants have held out until the last moment. One by one this was and is being tackled.  Interestingly, one village was right in the centre of the runways and without this the project would have stalled.

Fast forward to today and different parties claim different figures for the available land-bank. These range from 80% – 97%. Satellite imagery shows that most of the land bank has been leveled (thus presumably acquired). That said, some structures do remain and it is imperative these be removed, planned around or relocated.

In between all this the project slowly crawls forward.

Attracting private bidders was a challenging proposition

The airport was proposed as a Private Public Partnership venture with the Maharashtra Government holding 26% stake while the private developer would be given 74%. Global tenders were invited in 2014. Nine were received and four were shortlisted.

The four bidders included Tata Realty and Infrastructure Ltd, Hiranandani Developers Pvt, GVK and GMR. The first two did not provide financial bids and thus did not make the final list. GVK which ran the Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj International Airport in Mumbai offered to share 12.60% of the revenue of the new airport with City and Industrial Development Corp. of Maharashtra (CIDCO) as oopposed to GMR Infrastructure which offered 10.44%. GVK was awarded the bid.

With the bids complete, Prime Minister Modi was invited for the ground breaking ceremony for the Navi Mumbai International airport in Mumbai on 18 February 2018. The project had come to a stage where it could at the very least make its way to the runway. However, the clearance for takeoff still had challenges.

After being in the planning and execution stages for 12 years by 2018 the Navi-Mumbai airport project had cleared all the initial hurdles. Or so it was believed anyway. The next step was arranging the financing for the airport. Despite being the most expensive airport project till date estimated at USD 2.2 billion dollars, the cash-flows for the most part were secured against Mumbai’s growing traffic numbers and also its geo-strategic location as a key commercial capital. But this too would change in ways unimagined.

Project financing: from guaranteed success to now in question

Any airport project requires huge capital commitments. For the most part investors are not wary. This because regulated costs are recovered via pass-through charges to the passengers, while other costs would are recovered via items such as retail outlets, parking charges, commercial property development etc. It is a model that has provided for handsome returns to airport operators even while being misaligned to market demand and putting the burden of cost overruns and largesse squarely on passengers.

In the case of Navi-Mumbai airport, fairly certain of success, financiers were comfortable with the associated risks. The GVK group that at the time was operating both Mumbai and Bengaluru’s airports had a good credit rating. Overall there was no cause for concern. By July 2018 the project had achieved financial closure via a consortium of banks. The initial phase would require 10,000 crores. The lead arranger was Yes Bank. Ironically in 2010 when Yes Bank ran into liquidity constraints, the State Bank of India had to step in to take over as the lead arranger. This also resulted in further delay to the project.

As of now, the 26% equity holder (CIDCO), a Maharashtra owned corporation, has raised concerns about breach of certain agreements. This is delaying the financial closure that is critical to the new airport. While the new arranger, namely SBI, has taken over the loan portfolio, however, it has put preconditions. Critical amongst these is that the full land-bank of 1160 hectares should be put up as collateral so that the bank can take a first-charge and structure the financing accordingly.

Overall, given the broader outlook both for aviation and infrastructure, it is likely that bankers will revisit all the projections. Further delays on account of financing cannot be ruled out.

Parallel infrastructure: critical to the project is also delayed

The Navi-Mumbai project was and is dependent on transportation links being developed in other parts of the city. These included Extending the Bandra-Worli Sealink via a 42km costal road; the construction of a trans harbor link connecting Mumbai and Navi-Mumbai; a proposed 7.5 – 10 km bridge connecting Mumbai with Navi Mumbai;  widening the existing highway; building waterways & related infrastructure connecting Navi-Mumbai; and a metro-link direct to the airport.

These above links are critical for project success given that airport traffic flows have destinations that include large parts of the primary and secondary business districts, majority of the hotels and most of the sites of historic and cultural importance. Thus without these many segments of demand will simply default to the current airport (impacting project viability).

That said, many of the planned infrastructure upgrades find themselves delayed and awaiting decisions. And with cumulative costs in excess of USD 12bn (by conservative estimates), the jury is out on how soon these see light of day. Each passing day impacts project returns and thus it is in the best interest of all parties to come to consensus and take binary decisions. Yet that is easier said than done and much like earlier socio-political realities continue to impact progress.

Whether Mumbai needs a 2nd airport is not even a question…

Given the challenges and delays, and now the pandemic, a question that is coming up is whether the 2nd airport is even needed. To understand why this is not even a question, one has to examine the city and trends that have seen the emergence of secondary business districts. These are emerging to as important centers of growth due to presence of well-maintained spaces, rental and fixed costs less than 45%-60% as compared to primary business districts, incentives and subsidies offered, as well as proposed proximity and connectivity to the upcoming airport.

Residential real-estate prices have also led to much of the population spreading to outward areas which includes first-time homebuyers, young families, first-second generation, students and the growing middle class. In addition to real-estate prices, transport is a key determinant of where populations reside. This because ~45% of Mumbai’s working population uses public transit. It is said that Mumbai is a city that operates on a handful of train-tracks. Thus it is imperative, that to leverage these dynamics, connectivity links also evolve.

An airport forms part of the overall key value proposition of the city which then translates to growth and jobs. This has already been witnessed in cities like Delhi and Mumbai. In Delhi the National Capital Region (NCR) has seen disproportionate growth in Gurugram in the state of Harayana which is in proximity to the airport. Similar growth has not been seen in areas such as Noida in the state of Uttar Pradesh which earlier had the same level of development including proximity to a Special Economic Zone. The new airport in Jewar is an attempt to correct this imbalance.

For Mumbai, real-estate prices coupled with connectivity woes have already started to impact decisions taken on where to locate business.  Technically, Mumbai airport is fully saturated and not able to accommodate any new flights. And real-estate prices, while depressed, continue to be unviable for folks that choose not to move out to the greater metropolitan region.

Finally, Navi-Mumbai as it stands will be the costliest airport project the country has seen thus far. Which also means it will likely have high user charges. These would otherwise have been managed as the owner of both airports was common, but the industry is now factoring in a presumable change in ownership of Navi-Mumbai. This based a letter written by an entity of the Maharashtra State government (CIDCO) to the promoters of the Navi-Mumbai airport asking for proof of the financial capability to see the project till completion within the stipulated deadline.

As of this writing, the story of the second airport in Mumbai remains unfinished.

89 thoughts on “A Story Of Airport To Nowhere: Is Navi Mumbai Airport Finally Ready To Take Off?

  1. Sir I congratulations your team for achument the very major task for preparation the airport in the difficult ground.

  2. Hi i have been listing about Navi Mumbai airport from last 15 years actualy wl that Airport will built or not as ever since i hv been getting news soon wl start that has taken 15 years still we dont have exact date when wil new airport will start operating, if u know pls give us dates.
    Thanks

  3. Because of Navi Mumbai Airport i bought property in Khargar at very high price so i am wondering when wl be complited.
    Nanik Moorjani

  4. Very Balance article .. journey of 2 decades is sum up very nicely…! It’s a complete flash back; being associated with the Industry, I am following NMIA since then.

  5. I needed to put you that bit of remark so as to give thanks the moment
    again on the spectacular principles you’ve featured on this
    site. It’s so open-handed of you to provide without restraint exactly what many
    individuals could have distributed as an ebook to earn some dough on their own,
    notably since you might have done it in the event
    you decided. The concepts in addition worked to become great way to fully grasp other
    individuals have the same keenness just like my very own to know the truth very much
    more with reference to this condition. I know there
    are numerous more enjoyable occasions ahead for
    many who look over your blog.

  6. This flowery succulent is warmth, drought, and salt tolerant and blooms in intense colours
    together with hot pink, yellow, orange, white, and purple from summer season to fall.

  7. Yesterday, while I was at work, my sister stole my iphone and tested to see if
    it can survive a 25 foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad
    is now broken and she has 83 views. I know this is completely off
    topic but I had to share it with someone!

  8. This is the right web site for anyone who wants to find out about this
    topic. You understand a whole lot its almost tough to argue with you (not that I actually
    will need to?HaHa). You definitely put a brand new spin on a subject that’s been discussed for a long time.
    Wonderful stuff, just excellent!

  9. Oh my goodness! Amazing article dude! Thank you, However I am having problems with your RSS.
    I don’t understand the reason why I am unable to subscribe to it.
    Is there anybody getting identical RSS issues?
    Anyone who knows the solution can you kindly respond?
    Thanx!!

  10. I do consider all of the ideas you have presented on your post.
    They are very convincing and can certainly work.
    Nonetheless, the posts are too quick for novices.
    May just you please extend them a bit from subsequent time?
    Thanks for the post.

  11. A good way to decide on a vet is to see if he or
    she solutions your questions promptly and knowledgeably and to see
    how they interact along with your pet.

  12. There’s no higher place to community, learn, and meet up with the buddies and colleagues who make
    veterinary medicine so rewarding.

  13. Over the years we’ve observed that many pretend and manipulated photographs of succulents are the ones that go viral on social
    media websites like Pinterest and Instagram.

  14. times, earrings has been used to beautify the allure and beauty of each women and men. One of the maximum essential jewelry objects is the wedding band, which is made of different valuable metals

  15. I was wondering if you ever thought of changing
    the structure of your site? Its very well written; I love what youve
    got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better.
    Youve got an awful lot of text for only having 1 or 2 images.
    Maybe you could space it out better?

    Visit my page – 강남홀덤; Junko,

  16. Just desire to say your article is as surprising. The clarity on your put
    up is just great and i can assume you are an expert on this subject.

    Fine together with your permission let me to snatch your
    RSS feed to keep updated with approaching post. Thanks 1,000,000 and please
    keep up the rewarding work.

    Take a look at my web-site 안전 토토 사이트

  17. braveness to come up in front of an unknown target audience to sing songs even in the face of feasible humiliation. The desire of track for a karaoke consultation relies upon at the form of audience it is being

  18. serious issues no longer best in your skin, however also in your fitness. Hormone disruptions, start defects, organ damage…Even pores and skin most cancers or breast cancer might also result from toxic

  19. In male dogs, neuter surgical procedure protects him against testicular most cancers – it could additionally present behavioral advantages.

  20. Another is the smoothie weight loss plan. The smoothie weight loss plan has been beneficial for many decrease carbohydrate energy, your body turns to saved fat to break down into glucose. Over a time frame, this ends in burning off the fat shops in adipose tissue – which is what ends in fats loss. This does now not necessarily must be a prolonged procedure. In a nice software known as the 14 day rapid fats

  21. Some studies have shown it to reduce the visible signs of aging. Hops РUsed for its antioxidant and antibacterial properties. Also makes great beerļ Hyaluronic Acid РIs a natural compound found in skin. It is used as a water binding agent, drawing moisture to the skin. Hydrolized Wheat Gluten РA compound derived by hydrolyzing wheat with water. Used in conditioners as a softening and

  22. the pounds during those quarantine days and looking to lose weight then pick your food regimen carefully. A popular and trusted one that provides on its promise of a tremendous end result is the custom made keto healthy eating plan. Note: There’s no instantaneous in a single day restoration for

  23. day bachelor and bachelette’ opportunity sex. Ladies are greater regularly open to trying out some yoga focusing on flexibility and toning of their legs, every can absolutely gain from taking a look over the

  24. same – body water loss. However, diets that hire have extreme caloric regulations or which might be excessive in protein can appreciably boom this impact. Actually, the natural path of weight reduction is to enjoy a quick lack of weight on account of the loss of water from frame tissues that is then sooner or

  25. exponentially. The “recuperation the beyond” technique with the “recovery the beyond” method you can loose yourself of your masculine vocal styles and behavior and cleanse your mind, frame, and

  26. case of male sexual disorders which might be caused by physiological troubles, surgical operation is the handiest alternative. These days, several alternatives are available that are painless and fast. K so, i watched the olympics, specifically i’m interested in song and subject activities due to the fact i used to be a star athlete in high school and university. My mom likes the swimming events as she made the usa

  27. que les régimes amaigrissants sont leur alternative la plus efficace pour une bonne santé. Malheureusement, personne qui désire diminuer ne le fait d’une manière saine. La perte de poids est

  28. in your area. 6: Join a weight loss help group. Receive help and encouragement from other dieters, there Consuming Much Less Fat – But Do It Accurately Reducing the consumption of excessive fat in your meals. Finally, gaining extra energy than your body uses will benefit your weight. You will honestly shed

  29. diet. Your doctor may also suggest a few specific weight reduction packages that would be right for you. Author Jana Beutler Holland, M.Ed., is a former English teacher, therapist and juvenile probation officer.

  30. forth with the aid of the arena health company (1999), research of assisted reproductive technology programs display decrease being pregnant charges with much less than 15% normal forms.

  31. You ought to create a calorie deficiency so as for you body to begin shedding pounds. If you do no longer start to limit how lots meals you take in no quantity of workout will assist you attain your dreams.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.